The Batchman Family’s Open Adoption Journey

In a world where dreams sometimes feel distant, Casey and Michael found themselves navigating a path they hadn’t initially envisioned—one that led them to their beautiful daughter, Natalee, through the open adoption program at Catholic Charities of Southwest Kansas.
The Batchmans, married in 2017, embarked on their family journey with hope and anticipation. Yet, as Casey shared, “We spent the next few years going to different specialists and trying to figure out what our cause of infertility was… It was not the funnest journey.” The emotional and financial toll of infertility was significant, leading them to consider adoption, although it was not initially at the forefront of their plans.
Finding support for open adoption
Their journey took a pivotal turn in January 2023 when a family friend unexpectedly reached out, suggesting adoption, a sign Casey and Michael took to mean, “this is your next step.” Recalling this moment, Casey noted, “That was our sign that we needed to explore this and go down that road.” This decision led them to Catholic Charities, where they were welcomed by adoption social worker Lori Titsworth, who Casey described as making them “feel like we were part of a family.”
The path to adoption was not without its challenges. Casey reflected on the difficulty of creating their adoption profile, feeling like “average Joes” with so much to offer but unsure how to convey that on paper. Yet, through it all, they found support and camaraderie in their community and fellow prospective adoptive parents. “We thoroughly enjoyed meeting the other couples… because it made us feel like we were not alone,” Casey shared.
Connecting with Natalee’s birth parents
Meeting Natalee’s birth parents, Tia and Josh, was a significant step in their journey. Casey recalled feeling “nervous” but ultimately forming a connection, symbolized by her instinct to hug Tia, which “broke the ice.” The strength and resolve of Tia were evident, and Casey expressed deep respect for her courage and the open relationship they have cultivated.
Welcoming Natalee
When the moment finally came to meet Natalee, Casey described it as being “paralyzed in love,” with everything else in the world fading away. Michael echoed this sentiment, saying, “It was an instant bond. I fell in love instantly.” The Batchmans cherished their private time with Natalee before sharing the joyous news with family, creating a surprise that was “the greatest.”
Casey and Michael’s story is a testament to the transformative power of open adoption, a journey filled with uncertainty, hope, and ultimately, profound joy. Their experience with Catholic Charities provided them the guidance, support, and compassion needed to navigate this path. “It’s scary,” Casey admitted, “but we knew that God brought us there for a reason.”
Encouragement for other families
For those contemplating adoption, Casey offers heartfelt advice: “Just going and talking to Lori or to a caseworker, even if you’re scared… helps a lot because they truly care.” Their journey underscores the importance of faith and community, and the assurance that love, in its many forms, can build a family.
As they look to the future, Casey and Michael are committed to giving Natalee a good childhood, filled with love, support, and understanding of her adoption story. They hope to maintain a healthy relationship with Tia and Josh, acknowledging, as Lori noted, that “it’s a fluid relationship that’s going to change over time.”
The Batchmans’ journey is not just a celebration of Natalee’s arrival but an invitation for others to explore open adoption as a path to family. For those facing infertility, Casey’s story is a beacon of hope, illustrating that even in the valleys, there can be a clear path forward, guided by love and faith.
Take the next step
Explore adoption support and resources, or contact Catholic Charities of Southwest Kansas.






